J.J. McCarthy
QB
NYG
Age 23
QB32
Dynasty 1QB
71
Overall 211
Superflex
244
+244% vs 1QB
Player facts
Age
23
Height
6′3″
Weight
219 lb
College
Michigan
Season
3rd
Jersey
#18
Expert rank
212.5
Where he sits
All 95 ranked quarterbacks by dynasty value, log scale.
- QB12 — where a 12-team league runs out of starting slots1,802
- QB32 — J.J. McCarthy71
QB32 of 95, 1,731 short of it, with 63 priced below him.
What makes up his value
- Consensus rank7397%
- Age curve-23%
At 23 the age curve takes 2 points off him — 97% of what the same consensus rank is worth at the QB peak of 24-30.
The QB age curve
What his consensus rank is worth at every age, holding that rank constant.
Quarterbacks peak at 24-30.
What would have to change
1,731 to a starting job
A QB12 season prices at 1,802. At 23 he is past the QB peak of 24-30, so the age curve is working against him as well as the depth chart.
Value over time
-1 across 8 snapshots
Value by format
| League | Value | vs base |
|---|---|---|
| Dynasty, 1QB | 71 | 0% |
| Dynasty, superflex | 244 | 244% |
| Redraft, 1QB | 71 | 0% |
| Redraft, superflex | 246 | 246% |
What he costs in picks
A pick package that reaches J.J. McCarthy’s 1QB dynasty price of 71.
- 2027 Early 3rd66
- 2026 Pick 5.075
- Package total71
Within the ±5% fair band.
Comparable players
| Player | Pos | Age | Value | Gap | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shedeur Sanders | QB | 24.7 | 71 | — | Compare |
| Pat Freiermuth | TE | 28 | 70 | -1 | Compare |
| Geno Smith | QB | 36.1 | 70 | -1 | Compare |
| Cade Otton | TE | 27.5 | 70 | -1 | Compare |
| Rashod Bateman | WR | 26.9 | 75 | +4 | Compare |
| Tank Bigsby | RB | 25.2 | 67 | -4 | Compare |